Obama and McCain air China views through AmCham China

obama-mccain-0915.jpgIn articles written exclusively for AmCham's China Brief magazine, US presidential candidates John McCain and Barack Obama have outlined their visions for US-China relations if they were to come to power.

From Obama:

In the coming years, the United States and China face challenges that require fresh thinking and a change from the US policy approach of the past eight years. How the US and China meet these challenges, and the extent to which we can find common ground, will be important both for our own countries and for others in Asia and beyond.

China has achieved extraordinary, sustained growth over the past three decades. Hundreds of millions of people in China live better now than most thought possible even two decades ago.

But as China’s leaders acknowledge, China must make some basic adjustments if it is to continue sustained, shared economic growth. China must develop practices that are more environmentally sustainable and less energy intensive, that boost domestic consumption as an engine of growth, that enhance the social safety net, and that encourage indigenous technology innovation. Otherwise, the country’s future performance may fall well short of its potential... [Read more]

From McCain:
The resurgence of Asia is one of the epochal events of our time. It is a renaissance that is not only transforming the face of this vast region, but throwing open new opportunities for billions of people on both sides of the Pacific—Americans and Asians alike—to build a safer, more prosperous and freer world.

Seizing these opportunities, however, will require strong American leadership and an unequivocal American commitment to Asia, whose fate is increasingly inseparable from our own. It requires internationalism rather than isolationism, and global trade rather than national protectionism. When our friends and allies in the Asia-Pacific region think of the future, they should expect more—not less—attention, investment and cooperation from the highest levels of the US government.

A central challenge will be getting America’s relationship with China right. China’s double-digit growth rates have brought hundreds of millions out of poverty, energized the economies of its neighbors and produced manifold new economic opportunities. The US shares common interests with China that can form the basis of a strong partnership on issues of global concern, including climate change, trade and proliferation. But some of China’s economic practices, combined with its rapid military modernization, lack of political freedom and close relations with regimes like Sudan and Burma, tend to undermine the very international system on which its rise depends. The next American president must build on the areas of overlapping interest to forge a more durable US-China relationship... [Read more]

Our good friends from the China Law Blog have this to say about the two articles (and we can't help but agree):
The summary of both is that China has done great things(duh!), still has a ways to go(duh!), and the US should cooperate, except where it does not make sense to do so )duh!). Yada, yada, yada. One can hardly blame America for focusing more on Sarah Palin's glasses?
Now, what the two candidates have to say to Americans in China is one thing. Let's wait to see what they'll tell voters back home next.

Comments (7) [rss]

The states is so solidly fucked right now that's it's a wonder anyone other than Americans would listen to these guys at all.

The rest of the world is falling faster than we are.

From Obama's position paper:

"In the coming years, the United States and China face challenges that require fresh thinking and a change from the US policy approach of the past eight years."

This statement alone is bound to cause a little nervousness among China's leadership. Exactly what kind of "fresh thinking" and "change" will be required.

Later in the Obama position statement: "I know that America and the world can benefit from trade with China, but only if China agrees to play by the rules and act as a positive force for balanced world growth."

What does this mean--"... but only if China agrees to play by the rules"? What rules is Obama talking about here? This almost comes across as a threat.

And later yet, Obama says: "Central to any rebalancing of our economic relationship with China ...." Rebalancing of our economic relationship? Is Obama saying the current economic structure between the U.S. and China is unacceptable?

This is all very powerful stuff and is sure to cause anxiety in China and around the globe.

What a poor post by both Shanghaiist and China Law Blog.
Instead of mashing out a sarcy summary, why don't you try some real journalism. Analyze and distinguish the two candidates. And there are some clear differences in both style and content.
McCain puts US Internationalism at the center of his argument, and provides clear criticisms of specific Chinese domestic and foreign policy.
Obama writes vaguely about 'shared economic growth' and his political criticisms are only mentioned at the end, and are not as clear or to the point as MccAIn.

It's a shame Shanghaiist and other blogs can only compete with the big players on the sensationalist sex stories or earthquake facts. Google News is better at churning out news stories, if thats all Shanghaiist wants to be.

I would like to see a direct question on Taiwan during the debates.

user-pic

Suffice it to say that McCain supports the current regime's policy of being an international bully, using threats (mostly empty now) to coerce others into submission. Obama advocates increased dialog among world leaders to address a mutually beneficial existence.

So which would you prefer?

@eastwest: China needs to worry about Barack Obama? The whole theme of his campaign is "change" so naturally that tagline appears in his position paper. Now that McCain is another story: he wants to browbeat the world like the idiot Bush. Hopefully the voters here in the states will relieve the world of the task of dealing with him.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Personals

Enter our FREE personals site!

Tips

About Shanghaiist

Shanghaiist is a website about Shanghai, China.

Managing Editor: Dan Washburn
Editor: Kenneth Tan
Publisher: Gothamist

About | Advertising | Archives | Arts/Entertainment | Contact | Contribute | Facebook | Favorites | Feedburner | Food/Drink | Jobs | Mobile | News | Other | Personals | Popular | RSS | Staff | Top Users | Twitter | Write For Us





Recent Comments

Contribute

Latest Tip:


[more]

Latest Photo:

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Shanghaiist.

All Our RSS