Quantcast

Modern Chinese rockers staying far away from politics

juefestival26.jpg While rock is currently experiencing a revival all over this country, the spirit of revolution inherent in the first generation of Chinese alternative music is noticeably absent.

According to the AFP, this wave of new rockers are careful to avoid politics. Carsick Cars and their popular song “Zhongnanhai” is specifically mentioned. “Zhongnanhai” could be translated either into a brand of cigarettes or the seat of China's communist government. Carsick Cars insist it's about the smokes.

It's a far cry from the rock scene in the 1980s. Cui Jian, known as the “father of Chinese rock,” wrote “Nothing to my Name,” the anthem for the Beijing student protests. When those went sour in 1989, he was banned from performing at major venues in the country. The ban was only lifted in 2000.

In comparison:

"Chinese musicians know that there are certain lines they can't cross," said Michael Pettis, owner of D-22 and producer of Carsick Cars. "All CDs, if they are going to be nationally distributed, have to be approved by censors."

According to Shen Lihui, head of China's biggest independent music label Modern Sky, the post-Tiananmen generation "is just not that interested in politics".

"What he (Cui) said was what everyone wanted to say, so he was an icon. But now, if musicians sang this type of content, people wouldn't be interested," he said.

"People in the '80s grew up in the 1970s, and they had a lot of restrictions, so politics were important for them. But now, young people just don't have so many restrictions."

So much for actually being punk, eh?

Contact the author of this article or email tips@shanghaiist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Yeah, the AFP article is terrible.



    Carsick Cars are not in a genre associated with political agitation at all.



    And, how many bands within rock or punk back home are overtly political and talk directly about gov policy? Not many. If we think The Cars are 'punk' in that sense, then where's the next post asking why Cold Play aren't singing about abolishing the House of Lords and taking down all the security cameras.



    Then, within the context of China, most bands on the underground scene are unacceptable to the Xinhua standard for TV and national distribution by either lyrics, look or lifestyle. And some bands do sing about issues and alternative lifestyles, like The Subs.



    What we need is some nuance, not a bunch of 'experts' projecting their big China views onto everything. Just reminds me of Japan discourse in America where they do something good and it's written off as copying or whatever.

  • kristhedabendan

    "So much for actually being punk, eh?"



    Who is this person to decide who is and who isnt punk? Last time i saw Carsick Cars they weren't seeking anyones approval on their punk-o-meter. They were just blasting out good tunes and in a country with almost zero CD sales it certainly wasnt for the cash.

blog comments powered by Disqus

personals

Enter our FREE personals site!

send a tip

tips@shanghaiist.com