Quantcast

Skepticism follows Yunnan prison death's citizen investigation

humanfleshsearch.jpg By Richard Yu

The Yunnan government made a surprisingly open move this week by appointing a famous blogger to head an internal investigation over the suspicious death of a 24-year-old inmate. But after all the investigation produced was a "meaningless" report, many are wondering if the whole deal wasn't much more than a PR stunt.

Li Qiao Ming, who was in jail for illegal logging, had died of head trauma. Depending on who you asked, Li was either the victim of a prison yard beat down or (according to the police) just an unlucky fellow who ran headlong into a concrete wall during a game of “elude the cat.”

Netizen skepticism over the police report prompted a second investigation by the Yunnan government, this time headed by citizens - including bloggers like Zhen Li and locals chosen through an online lottery.

It seemed like a great leap towards government transparency... until the investigative committee's report came out...

From China Daily:

The 7,200-word report detailed the committee's one-day visit to Jinning prison on a timeline, and recounted conversations between the members and the government officials on a word-for-word basis. However, it made no attempt to determine the cause of Li's death.

"This report is definitely not the one that 'deciphers' or 'exposes the truth of' the incident of 'hide-and-seek', we can only guarantee that our conscience and responsibility is served on this day, the rest is for members of online community to discuss," the report concludes.

The committee had no access to police tapes or first-hand witnesses, rendering the whole effort more or less "meaningless."

But the gov't must have known a candidly useless report would never satisfy the online masses, who responded to the disappointing report by hacking into the official government website.

So was the new investigation was merely a cheap publicity stunt or a genuine baby step towards government accountability? It's unfortunately hard to tell.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@shanghaiist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • James Creegan

    Even if it's not true, I still like the mental image of a prison yard full of hardened criminals playing kissy-chase.

  • LoveChinaLongTime

    Everyone knows Hide-n-seek is deadly business!! Play at your own risk...

  • This just in:



    Former Sha-ist editor Kenneth Tan accidentally bludgeoned to death with sticks during a particularly heated game of hopscotch in police custody.

  • Little Weasel

    ah, didnt think marks like will make my contents disappear. "blackadder" "dish and dishonesty"

  • Little Weasel

    "the Acting Returning Officer, Mr. E. Blackadder, of course. And we’re all very grateful, indeed, that he stepped in at the last minute, when the previous Returning Officer accidentally brutally stabbed himself in the stomach while shaving.

    " --- season 3,eposide 1

blog comments powered by Disqus

personals

Enter our FREE personals site!

send a tip

tips@shanghaiist.com

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Ovid: "It's useful that there should be Gods, so let's believe there are."
[more]

Latest Photo: