Quantcast

Christie's auction hurt the feelings of the Chinese people

YSL_heads_1106860c.jpg Sina.com had a survey up about the recent Christie's auction, in which two bronze animal heads looted from the Summer Palace in the 1719th century fetched 15.7 million euros. The survey results, translated into English, were thus:

Should Christie's be banned from China?

Yes, Christie's auction goes against international treaties and has hurt the feelings of the Chinese people. (91.6%)

No, this is nothing but a simple business activity (7.3%)

Are you satisfied with the current state of protection for cultural artifacts?

Not satisfied. Over the years, artifacts have continued to be leaked to the outside world. The relevant bodies should inspect this. (88.5%)

Satisfied. Cultural artifacts are protected more and more. (8.0%)

Over the years, many Chinese cultural artifacts have been auctioned off, yet the attitudes of the Chinese people have been overall peaceful. Why do you think this auction is so controversial?

The relics were from the Second Opium War and represent China's humiliation. (48.8%)

The French tried to connect human rights issues to the sale of the cultural artifacts (33.6%)

The media had not paid special attention to this before (15.9%)

One group of Chinese lawyers already filed a lawsuit earlier this month with the Tribunal de Grande Instance in Paris, asking for an injunction of the auction. But the court ruled against their demand.

Undaunted, the 81-person-strong group has said that it would seek to learn the identities of the buyers and possibly negotiate for the return of the bronzes.

Superstar Jackie Chan was so incensed that he felt he had to make a movie about it, according to The Standard:

''They remain looted items, no matter whom they were sold to. Whoever took it out [of China] is himself a thief,'' he fumed to reporters in Hong Kong. ''It was looting yesterday. It is still looting today.''

The action star said he is planning a movie about the search for and return of some of China's stolen national treasures from the palace. Filming is scheduled to start next year.

''But now we lost two more pieces. This made me really angry,'' he said.

Note: I left out the "Undecided" votes because they were boring and never amounted to more than 3.5%

Contact the author of this article or email tips@shanghaiist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • you people make me sick, have any of you people even been to china? Studied chinese history?? These are prized artifacts and symbols of heritage to the chinese people, a nation of 1.3 billion. That is something priceless. These were looted stolen artifacts, they were stolen then and they are still considered stolen today. The day will come when the chinese people, whose previous generations suffered at the hands of western imperialism, will have the last say. Until then, continue to delude yourselves, you guys are good at that.
  • mahesh

    Auction Direct USA is changing how you shop, buy and sell used cars. We're in the New York used cars market, the Jacksonville used cars area and the Raleigh used cars market now.The lowest prices and the best selection make shopping for used cars easier than ever.



    Our unique auction atmosphere creates a truly enjoyable buying experience. The used car business will never be the same. See how we're making it easier to buy used cars.

    ------------

    mahesh77

    auctions-auctions

  • ha - eastman - most original way to stop US occupation i've heard !!

  • RUSHOUR1

    original? i only copied it from that french dude who wanted to swap his animal head with tibet independence.

  • RUSHOUR1

    oh boy, agreed completly.

    but let me teach you: nobody in china ever demand yank marines withdraw from iraq as a condition to stop sale of "pirate watches, bags, and DVDs".

  • so 91 percent of peeps hate christies.



    how many want to free tibet ?



    [if china dealt w/ that, france would've likely given these back!]

  • Elaine Chow

    Sorry, my bad math at play. I meant to say 19th.

  • RUSHOUR1

    --"looted from the Summer Palace in the 17th century"?

    it was looted much later, in 1860.

  • Pirx

    Oh, they just love to be victims, don't they?



    Why not copy that stuff a couple of thousand times, just like everything else? Then everyone who wants can have one.

  • RUSHOUR1

    chinese feel angry mostly because of ridiculars blackmail that connected 1860 loot with pla 1950 march into tibet.

    meanwhile you sure cannot feel the same since your beloved usa has nothing old to be looted.

  • McLustin

    Wow, the point went completely over your head. Let me put it directly: the pirate watches, bags, and DVDs that are rampant on the streets are also forms of looting. I note that it doesn't seem to be as much of a concern at Sina.com.

  • RUSHOUR1

    oh McLustin boy, agreed completly.

    but let me teach you: nobody in china ever demand yank marines withdraw from iraq as a condition to stop sale of "pirate watches, bags, and DVDs".





  • EL JEFE

    Eastman, I have a suspicion that you aren't even a real person.

blog comments powered by Disqus

personals

Enter our FREE personals site!

send a tip

tips@shanghaiist.com

recent comments