Quantcast

Everything (almost) that's happened with Google + China so far

google_flowers.jpg
"illegal flower donations"
We're sure that by tomorrow morning, there will be an even bigger slew of news out about Google's recent move (including if they actually are talking to the government, we hear they are at least). But for tonight, here's the latest news on the matter.

You know how people were offering flowers up at the alter of Google in Beijing? That's not allowed anymore - security officers at Tsinghua University (right next to Google's offices) are asking you why you're buying flowers and demanding that it not be for the Big G. That's apparently propelled "Illegal flower donations" (非法獻花) to the first big internet meme of China 2010.

Meanwhile, quite expectedly, China's official state media has officially told all news portals to harmonize their news with Xinhua's/People's Daily's versions. Considering that China Daily's take on the whole ordeal was a boring two sentences, Chinese people not addicted to the internet probably aren't going to know much about this. According to Reuters, Xinhua has said that Chinese authorities are "seeking more information on Google's statement that it could quit China" and that "it is still hard to say whether Google will quit China or not. Nobody knows."

Wired quoted a source that said Google has tried to work to protect its employees from that "information seeking," timing the announcement so that its Beijing branch would know about what was happening before they arrived to work. “[Google is] really concerned about their safety and feels that there is a very real possibility that they will be interrogated,” the source said. “They have been [interrogated] numerous times before, and this time they could be arrested and imprisoned.”

As for the security breach, evidence is slowly leaking out that collaborates Google's concerns. China Hush talks about a blog post from someone two days ago that tried to prove his personal emails from his Gmail account were being accessed and screened by the GFW. There's also the interesting timing of a recent security update to Gmail, which they rolled out yesterday.

Oh yeah, hilarious hacking of the day: Baidu's taiwan site, baidu.tw, was hacked to show google.tw instead. Right now, The baidu.tw URL just turns up an empty page. Aw, that was fun while it lasted.

Anyhow, In case you hadn't gotten enough (or Jeremy Goldkorn's whetted your appetite) round up of opinions after the jump.

  • Hillary Clinton: "We have been briefed by Google on these allegations, which raise very serious concerns and questions. We look to the Chinese government for an explanation. The ability to operate with confidence in cyberspace is critical in a modern society and economy. I will be giving an address next week on the centrality of internet freedom in the 21st century, and we will have further comment on this matter as the facts become clear."
  • Chinese twitterers (translated by CDT): "@hecaitou: After Google leaves China, the world’s top three websites on Alexa —Google, Facebook and Youtube are all blocked in China. This is not an issue of Google abandoning China, but one of China abandoning the world."
  • Imagethief: "Google has taken the China corporate communications playbook, wrapped it in oily rags, doused it in gasoline and dropped a lit match on it."
  • Rebecca MacKinnon: "Google's decision was tough and is going to have a great deal of of difficult fallout. Still, based on what I know, I think Google has done the right thing. They are sending a very public message - which people in China are hearing - that the Chinese government's approach to Internet regulation is unacceptable and poisonous."
  • Chinayouren: "...the message sounds inconsistent and improvised, it is difficult to believe that it comes from a careful calculation. I wonder who really writes that blog, but if this really comes from Google executives it is scary, especially from the shareholders POV. Regardless of the real intentions of Google, my first assessment is that the post is a BAD decision."
  • Evgeny Morozov: "They knew pretty well what they were getting into. Now it seems they are playing the innocence card ... It's like they thought they were dealing with the government of Switzerland and suddenly realised it was China."
  • People's Daily opinionist: "Leaving? Google is pouting! 退出?谷歌在撒娇吧!"
Contact the author of this article or email tips@shanghaiist.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Christopher

    The Olympics are now over, and China can resume it's usual isolationist policy when it comes to the world

  • Rick in China

    Curious that people are posting at how much better Baidu's market share is.



    Yes, it's better, because they play ball with the government by censoring content. As a result, the government allows them to go ahead and post massive amounts of illegal IP protected content with little or no reprecussion.



    It's amusing to read China's gov't officials make their official responses about abiding by the law and welcoming internet companies when they block the most popular international websites/services and allow local businesses to steal IP in plain sight. Nothing new about that kind of ridiculous hypocrisy.

  • nanheyangrouchuan

    Well, business surveys from CNBC today suggest many companies in the US are under attack from chinky chong gay man ass fen qing based in China and CNBC commentators have openly asked "is business in China worth the cost of cyberwarfare and IP theft".



    Dirty, ugly, worthless china.

  • BBC1

    lambshaslik, does it pain you the chinky chong chinamen don't give a rat's arse about what you folks think. LOL!

  • nanheyangrouchuan

    If the 5 cent han-jobbers didn't care what the world thinks, they wouldn't swarm websites discussing China (such as the BBC's "have your say" regarding "should Google leave China" and you wouldn't go to such lengths on this site.

  • BBC1

    China shud use the in the face tactic of exposing google's own dirty laundry with uncle sam.



    google is threatening to leave china because of breach of privacy?



    google may not adhere to the contract it has to do business in china because of conscience reasons for privacy and human rights and 'don't be evil'(company motto).



    but consider this. ever since september 11 2001 our us government approved full unwarranted access to everybody's email and text messages and other communications. everything is filtered through the at&t telecommunications building in san francisco for our government to look for words and phrases and clues that deems harmful against the state of america. http://www.historycommons.org/entity.jsp?entity=at_t_1



    does 'don't be evil' not apply to the american government 'attacking' our emails without warrant?



    i would like to see google grandstand against the us government hacking our privacy as well! this is what called 'selective morality'.



    ongoing google vs china story. http://www.nydailynews.com/money/2010/01/13/2010-01-13_google_may_.html

  • BBC1

    Orpheus, you are also an an idiot. Why can't you accept the an opposing viewpoint? LOL! Google shud cut the crap and exit China. But they won't. Why? Because China is shaping upto be the world's most lucrative Internet Market. In the long term, its ambition to be the biggest and baddest will be thwarted. I am so happy that Google is (really) leaving China. Good riddance to them. I hope Google collapses and broken apart.

  • nyc4life

    This will hurt Chinese internet users more than it will hurt Google. Only 2% of Google's revenue comes from China; the rest comes from the 5 billion people who couldn't use Baidu even if they wanted to because of the language difference. Meanwhile 19% of Chinese internet users prefer Google, so this group will be missing out on (relatively) un-harmonized search results.



    (stats taken from http://edition.cnn.com/2010/TECH/01/13/google.china.analysis/index.html)



    In fact, standing up for free speech will probably translate into positive publicity, increased brand loyalty and improved market share for Google. And they know this full-well; that's the real reason for this move. Google has been around long enough to know that posting a blog entry like this would not be the right way to decrease censorship if that was their actual goal. So the only motivation for this move would be the PR benefits.



    And are those 19% of Chinese internet users pissed off at Google? No, they're laying flowers at Google's doorstep. Check out ChinaSMACK's coverage, the translated user comments are almost universally pro-Google. Google didn't create this situation: the CCP did by trying to read private emails that they had no business reading. But Google is dealing with it in a very ballsy way. Props to them.

  • Orpheus

    Clinton's measured words perhaps shed some light on how far Google will go: "the ability to 'operate with confidence in cyberspace' is critical in a modern society and economy".



    So it's less about "principles" than about operational difficulties.

    So Google will chicken out from an act of chickening out.



    Google will stay. China will lie. Baidu will try again.

  • Orpheus

    @waixingren: you were too kind to Baidu. Remember the notorious extortion in their ranking scheme? Web mafia, that's what Baidu is.



    Baidu is one of the most disgusting enterprises on earth. Fox News is like Mother Teresa alongside the "Hundred Poisons". I am sure Baidu has everything to do with the Google attacks.

  • Orpheus

    @BBC1: you are an idiot. An embarassment to people who wish China and Chinese well.

    Let me offer you this highly intellectaully accomplished observation:



    YO MAMA!

  • waixingren

    Google = ballsy international company that respects the rules of the game and has balls the size of Mt. Everest... did I mention they have balls? Big ones.



    Baidu = bastard step-child of a company that hides behind big brother while breaking every known IP law ever created... neither of which (baidu or big brother) have balls. Not even one.

  • rushour

    Google is smart only in finding a good excuse to leave CHina where it owes a pitiful 20% market share while Baidu has a handsome 65.

  • beastman

    hey assbreath what percent of the world's largest market does YOUR search engine control? fuck all? thats what I thought, now go back to eating jiangjun's corn hole.

  • rushour

    We are talking about Google's leaving China. is Google exiting "world market"?

    But who'll expect good logic from a drunk beast?

  • vladivostok

    We definitely need some nanheyangrouchuan goodness around here to balance 'em out.

  • nanheyangrouchuan

    I see the "wu mao dang" is out in force already. Down with Han-job!

  • BBC1

    Who needs wumaos when tons of money is made from one's portfolio of Baidu shares. Even Americans are cashing in. Last time I checked, Baidu shares soared 17 percent. LOLLLL!!



    Yes, Google, go away!

  • BBC1

    Google's influence must be cut down to size around the globe. It's new Nexus phone is a bust. Good news indeed.

  • rushour

    Seems all west media are pretending blind to the fact that many Chinese writors are preparing to suit Google for its violation of Intelectual Property Law with its "Digital Library", which is also part of reason for it to exit. I guess Mr. Eric Smith of IIPA can tell more.

  • KKraus

    Wait a minute - China has Intellectual Property Law? Who knew?

  • rushour

    Yes, Since China jointed IIPA in 1980, China has made quite some laws to protect copyrights, trade marks, patents and the writers'd rights which Google violated and which hypocrite west media knowingly and unfairly avoided mentioning at present.

    Meanhwile China's violation of those laws cannot legalize Google's violation.

  • KKraus

    "Intellectual Property for me, but not for thee" might sound like a convincing argument to rushour, but it's rather transparently ridiculous to everyone else.

  • BBC1

    The biadu.tw domain is not owned by Baidu. China shud tell Google to fcuk off or put up. LOL!

blog comments powered by Disqus

personals

Enter our FREE personals site!

send a tip

tips@shanghaiist.com

Contribute

Latest Tip:

Since I think of you as a chiller and a much more productive edition of me, I just printed out this
[more]

Latest Photo: