• ABOUT
  • ADVERTISE
  • SUPPORT
  • CONTACT
  • WORK
Monday, January 18, 2021
Shanghaiist
8 °c
Shanghai
7 ° Sat
6 ° Sun
6 ° Mon
5 ° Tue
5 ° Wed
9 ° Thu
  • NEWS

    The “world’s tallest swing” is now open in Chongqing and it looks absolutely terrifying

    Kid falls from second story while imitating Kobe Bryant’s fadeaway

    Guy wearing police uniform for “safety” pulled over by highway cops

    Dalian to test 190,000 residents after 3 new confirmed cases are reported

    One-legged Chinese baller inspires others with his hard work and three-point shot

    Chinese courier company caught using mannequins as security inspectors

    China opens another world’s longest glass-bottomed bridge in Guangdong province

    3-year-old girl and her grandma beaten with shovel in horrific “revenge” attack

    Workers spotted burning documents as US orders China to close its Houston consulate

    LOOK: Massive landslide blocks river in Hubei province

    IKEA to open new downtown location in Shanghai this week

    Hunan bus drivers block road to pass bag of betel nuts across opposite lanes

    Jilin driver delayed by 20 minutes by wild Siberian tiger relaxing on the road

    6-year-old boy drowns to death during first swimming lesson at public pool

    Neighbor smoothly catches toddler falling from 5th floor

    Dude spotted chillaxing on self-made raft on river in Chongqing during flood season

    Shanghai dude gets part of ear bitten off while stopping drunk guy from assaulting woman

    Woman mysteriously disappears from home in Hangzhou, leaving behind no trace

    Two women get stuck in elevator at home for 4 days, drink their own urine to stay alive

    Urumqi goes on lockdown as fears rise of a new coronavirus outbreak in Xinjiang

  • L!FE
  • FOOD
  • GALLERY
  • VIDEO

    WATCH: Colorized footage of life in Beijing a century ago

    Hunan high school turns gym into cafeteria to keep students separated

    Kung fu school reopens teaching students how to swing bricks from their balls

    Dancing aunties and uncles return to Wuhan sidewalks

    Xi Jinping actually made a joke!

    Shanghai dad builds Death Stranding like safety pod to protect baby from coronavirus

    Tag along on food tour of Lanzhou, the hometown of hand-pulled noodles

    Man smashes bus window, jumps out after being stuck in traffic for 20 minutes

    Scooter driver somehow survives being squashed by massive panes of glass

    How students at a Xuzhou primary school have taken jump rope to the next level

    How this Chinese martial arts master “jumps on water”

    Bringing your date to your studio apartment of great shame

    Male designer loses 25 kg, goes viral modeling women’s clothing

    Take a look inside Taiwan’s “most luxurious university dormitories”

    Racers take the stairs in 119-floor vertical marathon up the Shanghai Tower

    Meet China’s captivating “roly-poly girl” who defies gravity with a smile

    Awful Chinese propaganda rappers take on Hong Kong protests, sample Trump

    Trying the food at a Chinese Muslim wedding in Kaifeng

    What it’s like visiting home after living in China

    Watch this Chinese teen jump rope 228 times in just 30 seconds

  • TICKETS
    • FAQ
  • ★ BE A PATRON
    • ★ DONATE
No Result
View All Result
Shanghaiist
No Result
View All Result
Shanghaiist
No Result
View All Result

Is there a Chinese housing bubble?

by benjamincost
May 5, 2018
in News

what-bubble.jpg
Image credit: Gaëtan Bruneteau.


landed-china.jpg Shanghaiist is pleased to present this exclusive excerpt from Landed China: Key Local Knowledge You Need When Buying Property, by Christopher Dillon. Christopher is an award-winning author who has previously written about buying property in Hong Kong and Japan.
Is there a bubble?
As this book went to press, many people were debating whether China was in the middle of a real estate bubble. The answer to that question is complex and a lot is riding on it. If you include the full spectrum of related activities, real estate accounts for up to one-quarter of China’s economy, shaping demand for everything from Japanese construction equipment and Chilean copper to European furniture and Chinese cement.
The argument for a bubble…
Headlines like “Shanghai New Home Prices up 273% in 7 years” make a strong case for the existence of a bubble. At one point in 2010, home prices in Beijing were 22 times higher than the average annual income, putting home ownership beyond many people’s reach. One survey concluded that China has 64 million empty dwellings, many of them in cities like Kangbashi, Inner Mongolia, which was built to accommodate 300,000 people but houses less than 10% of that number. Since 2010, the central government has implemented a range of costly and unpopular measures to cool the property market, a course that the Chinese leadership was not likely to take unless it believed that a bubble was forming.
…and the case against
As economists Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff point out in their 2008 paper, “This Time is Different: A Panoramic View of Eight Centuries of Financial Crises,” the pervasive view that ‘this time is different’ is precisely why it usually isn’t different, and catastrophe eventually strikes again.” That said, there are parts of China’s experience that — if not different — are distinctive. For example, research by CLSA indicates that in 2011, one-third of all Chinese buyers paid cash for their homes, up from 24% in 2007. Furthermore, 53% of people buying a dwelling for investment purposes paid cash. In addition, there is a 30% minimum down payment for first homes, with higher minimums for subsequent purchases, and the exotic mortgages that fueled the American subprime crisis are not available in China.
There is also a strong cultural bias toward repaying debt. When property prices in parts of Hong Kong fell two-thirds after the 1997 Asian financial crisis, the mortgage default rate peaked at just 1.4%.
China has an overhang of empty homes, although the size of the surplus is open to debate, with some estimates placing the number at 16.6 million. A large proportion of these empty homes are held as investments because there are few other options. The inflation-adjusted returns on bank deposits and bonds are negative, China’s stock markets are notoriously fickle and most people cannot invest overseas. As a result, holding empty apartments is often the “least worst” choice.
There is also strong demand from end-users, with 93% of buyers planning to live in the homes they purchase. McKinsey estimates that China’s cities will add some 350 million inhabitants between 2005 and 2025, creating a need for 10 million new homes each year. Nearly one-third of the nation’s 225 million urban households don’t have a private kitchen or bathroom, so there is also demand from people upgrading their homes.
Luxury homes in the nation’s Tier 1 cities are undeniably expensive. But China is not a homogenous market, and a villa in a gated community in Beijing is no more representative of China than a penthouse in New York’s Central Park is typical of the United States.
Finally, there is little question of China reverting to a centrally planned economy. Deng Xiaoping’s doctrine of “socialism with Chinese characteristics” has been affirmed by China’s new leaders, and accumulated surpluses give China a significant financial cushion.
But is it the right question?
In the most dire predictions, China’s property bubble bursts and causes the nation’s financial system to collapse. In a worst-case scenario, the global financial system fails, too.
Like the central government, this author believes the threat of a bubble is real. But if you are an end-user who plans to live in China for the medium-to-long term and have a reasonably secure job, the patience to endure the market’s turbulence and a manageable debt load, you should be fine. There’s still the risk of losing your job in a global recession, a developer failing to complete a home bought off the plan or the insolvency of a local government.
Based on what psychologists call availability bias, I would be more concerned about documented — yet less dramatic — threats like air pollution than a housing bubble bursting, especially if you’ve done your homework and bought sensibly.
In the end, I agree with Professor Gregory M. Stein of the University of Tennessee College of Law. In his 2012 paper, “Is China’s Housing Market Heading Toward a US-Style Crash?,” Professor Stein concluded, “Anyone who claims to have a definitive answer to this question is overly confident.”
Who do you trust?
Your perception of the size and severity of China’s real estate bubble will be influenced by your information sources. In any market, it is unusual to hear developers, real estate agents and industry associations say anything other than “it’s a great time to buy.” In February 2006, the chief economist of the National Association of Realtors, David Lereah, famously published a book entitled Why the Real Estate Boom Will not Bust and How You Can Profit From It, just before the U.S. market collapsed.
The central government’s pronouncements are more balanced, with the country’s top leadership stating its unequivocal commitment to maintaining an orderly property market. China’s local governments tend to be more boosterish, lacking Beijing’s concern for the bigger economic picture. However, many analysts view Chinese government statistics as unreliable and subject to politically motivated manipulation. Frequently, provincial numbers do not square with national totals.
China attracts its detractors, like Jim Chanos and Marc Faber (also known as “Dr. Doom”), who are convinced that the country is on the verge of economic collapse. It also inspires more bullish sentiments. In 1993, Morgan Stanley executive Barton Biggs was famously quoted as saying that he was “tuned in, overfed and maximum bullish” on China. Today, that view is usually held by investment banks looking for business on the Mainland.
When you read comments like these, it’s important to remember that the media loves extreme, provocative statements, and that people like Chanos, Faber and Biggs are investors looking at the macroeconomic picture. The state of China’s economy is undeniably important, but it should be one of many factors that you consider when making a buying decision.
Excerpted from Landed China, by Christopher Dillon, www.landedbook.com, ISBN: 978-988-17147-4-9. © 2013 Dillon Communications Ltd. All rights reserved.



shanghaiist-jobs.jpg

Share this:

  • Pocket
  • Telegram
  • Print
Shanghaiist

© 2005-2018 Shanghaiist - China in bite-sized portions!

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Be a Patron
  • Join the Community
  • List Your Event
  • Be a Venue Partner
  • Submit a Gallery
  • Work with us
  • Privacy & Terms
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
  • L!FE
  • FOOD
  • GALLERY
  • VIDEO
  • TICKETS
    • FAQ
  • ★ BE A PATRON
    • ★ DONATE

© 2005-2018 Shanghaiist - China in bite-sized portions!