• ABOUT
  • ADVERTISE
  • SUPPORT
  • CONTACT
  • WORK
Sunday, February 28, 2021
Shanghaiist
8 °c
Shanghai
7 ° Sat
6 ° Sun
6 ° Mon
5 ° Tue
5 ° Wed
9 ° Thu
  • NEWS

    The “world’s tallest swing” is now open in Chongqing and it looks absolutely terrifying

    Kid falls from second story while imitating Kobe Bryant’s fadeaway

    Guy wearing police uniform for “safety” pulled over by highway cops

    Dalian to test 190,000 residents after 3 new confirmed cases are reported

    One-legged Chinese baller inspires others with his hard work and three-point shot

    Chinese courier company caught using mannequins as security inspectors

    China opens another world’s longest glass-bottomed bridge in Guangdong province

    3-year-old girl and her grandma beaten with shovel in horrific “revenge” attack

    Workers spotted burning documents as US orders China to close its Houston consulate

    LOOK: Massive landslide blocks river in Hubei province

    IKEA to open new downtown location in Shanghai this week

    Hunan bus drivers block road to pass bag of betel nuts across opposite lanes

    Jilin driver delayed by 20 minutes by wild Siberian tiger relaxing on the road

    6-year-old boy drowns to death during first swimming lesson at public pool

    Neighbor smoothly catches toddler falling from 5th floor

    Dude spotted chillaxing on self-made raft on river in Chongqing during flood season

    Shanghai dude gets part of ear bitten off while stopping drunk guy from assaulting woman

    Woman mysteriously disappears from home in Hangzhou, leaving behind no trace

    Two women get stuck in elevator at home for 4 days, drink their own urine to stay alive

    Urumqi goes on lockdown as fears rise of a new coronavirus outbreak in Xinjiang

  • L!FE
  • FOOD
  • GALLERY
  • VIDEO

    WATCH: Colorized footage of life in Beijing a century ago

    Hunan high school turns gym into cafeteria to keep students separated

    Kung fu school reopens teaching students how to swing bricks from their balls

    Dancing aunties and uncles return to Wuhan sidewalks

    Xi Jinping actually made a joke!

    Shanghai dad builds Death Stranding like safety pod to protect baby from coronavirus

    Tag along on food tour of Lanzhou, the hometown of hand-pulled noodles

    Man smashes bus window, jumps out after being stuck in traffic for 20 minutes

    Scooter driver somehow survives being squashed by massive panes of glass

    How students at a Xuzhou primary school have taken jump rope to the next level

    How this Chinese martial arts master “jumps on water”

    Bringing your date to your studio apartment of great shame

    Male designer loses 25 kg, goes viral modeling women’s clothing

    Take a look inside Taiwan’s “most luxurious university dormitories”

    Racers take the stairs in 119-floor vertical marathon up the Shanghai Tower

    Meet China’s captivating “roly-poly girl” who defies gravity with a smile

    Awful Chinese propaganda rappers take on Hong Kong protests, sample Trump

    Trying the food at a Chinese Muslim wedding in Kaifeng

    What it’s like visiting home after living in China

    Watch this Chinese teen jump rope 228 times in just 30 seconds

  • TICKETS
    • FAQ
  • ★ BE A PATRON
    • ★ DONATE
No Result
View All Result
Shanghaiist
No Result
View All Result
Shanghaiist
No Result
View All Result

Interview with Rebecca Karl: China’s Qing Dynasty anarcho-feminists

by Kenneth Tan
May 5, 2018
in News

anarcho-fem-qing.png
feminismbook.JPG Rebecca Karl is an associate professor of history at NYU who primarily studies 20th century Chinese history. Her recent book, co-edited with Dorothy Ko and Lydia Liu, translates and introduces the early twentieth-century writings of anarcho-feminist writer He-Yin Zhen, which were largely suppressed or overlooked by her male contemporaries.
Shanghaiist: Tell us about He-Yin Zhen
Rebecca Karl: He-Yin Zhen was not only a feminist, she was also an anarchist. Her history has been buried because she’s too feminist for the anarchists, she’s too anarchist for the Marxists, she’s too Marxist for the liberals…she’s too something for somebody. So she’s just not very well known. Her husband Liu Shipei, however, was a very famous intellectual of the late-Qing period, and when we started looking for her writing we found that all of her texts had been incorporated into the collected work of her husband.
SHist: She sounds a bit like Emma Goldman (late nineteenth century American anarchist). Can you tell me what her impact was?
RK: Well besides founding Natural Law, the journal that published the first Chinese translation of the Communist Manifesto, she also had an incredibly far-sighted perspective on the role of women. While other feminists understood women’s liberation in terms of contributing to the strength of the nation, as an anarchist she thought the state was a part of the problem. Thus, she brought a feminist critique of the state into the equation decades before any other feminist did so. She also brought an awareness of this idea she called nanv (男女). What she means by nanv is that all social relations incorporate within them the social relationship between men and women. This is still a disputed topic in feminist analysis, but it was way ahead of its time then.
SHist: Why should we care about He-Yin Zhen today?
RK: We should care about her today because many of her critiques still ring true. She was a strident critic of factory production, which was just beginning then. She was a critic of concubinage which has become pretty potent again between some Hong Kong and Taiwan businessmen who come to China and have 二太太 (second wives). While the issues Chinese women face today aren’t exactly the same — they aren’t — they are sufficiently similar in structure that He-Yin Zhens writings remain relevant and startling.
SHist: We’ve interviewed folks like Shaun Rein who have told us that Chinese capitalism has been great for gender equality. What’s your take on this?
RK: In May, I held a workshop with the twelve leading feminist thinkers about Marxism and Feminism in China and this was the entire discussion about which we could have no resolution. This is the big question, ok?
There is no doubt that the Maoist period, through the power of the state suppressed a series of what were called ‘evil practices’: concubinage, prostitution, and foot-binding. Since the 1980s we have seen a lot of these practices — well, fortunately not foot-binding — come roaring back just as socialist feminist institutions like the Women’s Federations have lost a lot of credibility. Let me be clear though, this isn’t about absolute standards of living for women but rather about the issue of relative equality with men.
Ultimately, because of the withdrawal of state support for feminism we see what happens, which is a real regression in gender relations, and a real regression in the status of women in society.
SHist: Rape and sexual assault has been a growing issue too. Has there been a change in the way this is perceived?
RK: During the Maoist period, rape was treated incredibly harshly, and was punished incredibly harshly and was not understood to be the women’s fault. What happens these days I think that there’s reversion back to some sort of conservative idea that if a woman gets raped it’s somehow her fault. That she dressed provocatively, that she acted provocatively, that she stimulated it or something.
SHist: On a different note, one of the most public figures in Chinese feminism is Ye Haiyan, who has gained fame for stunts such like going out and becoming a prostitute for a week. Do you think He-Yin Zhen and Ye Haiyan would have been friends or enemies?
RK: No. Enemies.
SHist: Enemies? Why? What do you think of her.
RK: Yeah, no. I’m not prepared to do a takedown of Ye Haiyan.
SHist: No?
RK: I mean I think Ye Haiyan has carved for herself a position and a forum in which she can raise what she considers to be the essential questions of Chinese feminism today. They wouldn’t be my questions and they wouldn’t be He-Yin Zhen’s questions. How’s that for a pretty moderate, mild critique?
Read a sample of The Birth of Chinese Feminism at Columbia University Press or buy the book at Amazon.com.
[By Patrick Lozada and Yining Su]



english-teaching-ad.png

Share this:

  • Pocket
  • Telegram
  • Print
Shanghaiist

© 2005-2018 Shanghaiist - China in bite-sized portions!

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Be a Patron
  • Join the Community
  • List Your Event
  • Be a Venue Partner
  • Submit a Gallery
  • Work with us
  • Privacy & Terms
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
  • L!FE
  • FOOD
  • GALLERY
  • VIDEO
  • TICKETS
    • FAQ
  • ★ BE A PATRON
    • ★ DONATE

© 2005-2018 Shanghaiist - China in bite-sized portions!